A Mother’s Pain When Her Child Strays
Every Catholic mother prays that her children will remain faithful to the teachings of the Church. She hopes they will grow in virtue, avoid sin, and walk in the truth. But often, children go astray. They may reject Church teaching, adopt sinful lifestyles, or make choices that grieve their mother’s heart. This kind of sorrow cuts deeply. It is a pain that is quiet, persistent, and difficult to share.
Still, even in this sorrow, there is reason to hope. Sometimes, God allows a lesser sin in a child’s life to protect that child from a greater evil. While all sin is harmful and should never be affirmed, God in His mercy may permit a lesser fault for the sake of a greater good. Understanding this principle can help Catholic mothers find peace, continue in prayer, and avoid despair.
Understanding God’s Permissive Will
The Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches that God does not cause moral evil. However, He permits it because He respects human freedom and knows how to draw good even from sin. This is called God’s permissive will.
We see this in the Catechism: “God is in no way, directly or indirectly, the cause of moral evil. He permits it, however, because He respects the freedom of his creatures and, mysteriously, knows how to derive good from it” (CCC 311).
St. Thomas Aquinas explains that God allows some evils so that greater goods may result. In the Summa Theologica, he teaches that God permits sin not because He wills it, but because He wills the greater good that can come through His response to it. God may allow sin in one moment to bring about repentance, humility, or conversion later.
This truth can bring comfort to a mother whose child is living in sin. While she should never approve of the wrongdoing, she can trust that God remains at work. His providence is never absent.
St. Paul Teaches That God Sometimes Gives People Over to Their Desires
In his letter to the Romans, St. Paul describes how God sometimes allows people to follow their sinful desires. He writes, “Therefore, God handed them over to impurity through the lusts of their hearts” (Romans 1:24, NAB).
This does not mean that God desires their sin. Instead, it shows that when a person persists in rejecting the truth, God allows them to experience the natural consequences of their actions. This handing over is not a final judgment, but a step along the road that may lead to repentance. God never stops seeking the soul. He may allow the person to fall for a time in order to bring about a deeper understanding of sin and a greater desire for redemption.
For a Catholic mother, this can be a source of hope. If her child has rejected the truth and embraced sin, God has not abandoned that child. He may be allowing this period as part of a greater work in the child’s life.
Balaam Wanted His Own Way, and God Allowed It
The Old Testament gives us a striking example of God permitting a man to follow his own will. In the Book of Numbers, the pagan prophet Balaam is invited to curse the people of Israel. At first, God tells him not to go. But when Balaam insists, God allows him to go with a warning: “Go with them, but only on the condition that you do exactly as I tell you” (Numbers 22:20, NAB).
God does not force Balaam to remain behind. He lets him follow his desire, but sets limits. Later, God even sends an angel and permits his donkey to speak to stop Balaam and warn him again. This shows that God can allow a soul to proceed along a dangerous path while still protecting and instructing them.
Catholic mothers can see in this story the mercy of God. Even when a child demands their own way, God does not abandon them. He places limits, sends warnings, and continues to call them back.
St. Augustine Was Allowed to Wander Before He Returned
St. Augustine’s early life was filled with pride, sensuality, and error. He embraced a heretical sect and fathered a child out of wedlock. Yet through all these years, his mother, St. Monica, prayed for his conversion. She followed him, wept for him, and fasted for his soul.
At one point, Monica tried to prevent him from traveling to Rome. She feared further corruption. But a holy bishop told her, “Let him go. It is not possible that the child of so many tears should perish.”
Augustine did go to Rome. There, he met St. Ambrose. There, his conversion began. God permitted him to wander for a time, but He did not let him go. Augustine himself later wrote, “You were within me, but I was outside, and there I sought you” (Confessions, Book X).
This story is well-known because it gives mothers courage. A child may fall into grave sin. That fall may even be permitted by God for the sake of a greater healing. But with persistent prayer and trust, a mother can hope in the mercy of God.
St. Catherine of Siena Records God’s Words About Permitted Sin
St. Catherine of Siena, a Dominican and Doctor of the Church, wrote down divine revelations she received during prayer. In one passage, God tells her that He sometimes allows sin not to destroy a soul, but to save it.
He says, “I permit these things not for their destruction, but for their salvation. I use even their sin to make them understand their weakness and return to Me.”
This is a powerful insight. God does not treat sin lightly, but He can use it. A mother may see her child making wrong choices and fear that all is lost. But God is working, even in the darkness. He sees what we cannot see.
What Catholic Mothers Should Do in These Trials
When a child lives in sin, the mother should not affirm the sin. Instead, she should continue to speak the truth with love. But she should also resist the temptation to panic or despair.
Most importantly, she should pray. Prayer is not a last resort; it is the most powerful action a mother can take. St. Monica’s example teaches us that tears, fasting, and perseverance matter.
She should entrust her child to the Blessed Virgin Mary. The Rosary, consecration to the Immaculate Heart, and simple daily devotions can offer comfort and strength.
She should also keep communication open. Even if her child rejects the Faith, the mother should remain present. She should offer quiet witness, gentle encouragement, and consistent love.
Finally, she should trust in God’s providence. God sees the whole story. What seems like a hopeless situation may be the very moment when the soul begins to turn back to Him.
The Parable of the Prodigal Son Reminds Us of the Father’s Patience
Jesus told the parable of the prodigal son to show us God’s mercy. The younger son demands his inheritance and wastes it on sinful living. But when he returns, the father runs to him, embraces him, and restores him.
God is like that father. He waits for the child to return. He sees them from afar. He does not force their return, but He watches and prepares to receive them.
Catholic mothers can trust that the Father in heaven is more patient, more loving, and more powerful than they are. He does not stop working. He does not stop loving.
Closing Words of Encouragement
If your child has turned from the Faith, take heart. You are not alone. The Church has always had mothers who suffer and pray for wayward children. The saints have walked this path. The Blessed Mother has also walked the path of silent suffering.
God may permit your child to experience the consequences of their choices. But He does so with the hope of bringing them back. He does not abandon. He waits. He calls. He loves.
Stay faithful. Keep praying. Trust in God.
Prayer for a Child Who Has Gone Astray
O Mary, Mother of Sorrows,
you stood faithfully beneath the Cross,
watching your Son suffer for the salvation of sinners.
You understand the pain of a mother’s heart
pierced with sorrow.
I place my child, who has wandered from the truth,
into your Immaculate Heart.
Protect her from all evil.
Intercede for her conversion.
Cover her with your mantle of mercy,
and lead her back to your Son, Jesus Christ.
O Holy Spirit, enlighten her mind.
Soften her heart.
Break the chains that bind her.
Let no sin be permanent, no darkness final,
no path too crooked for your grace.
Grant me the strength of St. Monica,
the patience of Our Lady,
and the faith to wait in hope,
trusting in God’s time and providence.
Through Christ our Lord. Amen.
St. Monica, pray for us.
St. Augustine, pray for us.
Our Lady of Sorrows, pray for us.
Mrs. Dania C. Michael, O.P.
Homeschool Support
Classical Liberal Arts Academy
Notes
Catechism of the Catholic Church. 2nd ed. Vatican City: Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 2019. https://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG0015/_INDEX.HTM
Holy Bible. New American Bible, Revised Edition. Washington, DC: United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, 2011. https://bible.usccb.org/
Thomas Aquinas. Summa Theologica. Translated by Fathers of the English Dominican . https://classicalliberalarts.com/category/summa-theologica/
Province. Benziger Bros. edition, 1947. https://www.newadvent.org/summa/
Augustine. Confessions. Translated by Henry Chadwick. Oxford University Press, 2008.
St. Catherine of Siena. The Dialogue. Translated by Algar Thorold. London: J.M. Dent & Sons, 1907. https://archive.org/details/dialogueofsainte00cat
