The Taming of the Shrew: Lessons for Catholic Mothers in Marriage and Parenting

by

Over the course of our marriage, my husband and I have watched Shakespeare’s play, The Taming of the Shrew, many times. At first, I loved it for its humor and drama. But as the years have passed, I’ve come to see it as something more—a mirror and a teacher.

When we were newly married, I was not unlike Katherina: headstrong, quick with words, and fiercely independent. My husband, on the other hand, bore a striking resemblance to Petruchio. He was steady, good-humored, unshaken by my sharp edges, and full of quiet confidence. He did not give in to my moods, nor did he retreat. Instead, he led with strength, patience, and love.

Looking back, I see how the Lord used the beginnings of our marriage to teach me humility, order, and trust. What once seemed like an outdated comedy now strikes me as a wise and even tender parable about love and leadership, about the healing that comes when a woman learns to rest in the strength of a good man.

The Taming of the Shrew is not a perfect allegory, but it has become a meaningful and instructive one for me. In this article, I hope to share with you what I’ve learned from this play—not only for our marriages as Catholic wives, but also for how we raise our daughters and our sons.

A Model for Family Life?

William Shakespeare’s play The Taming of the Shrew is not often recommended today as a model for family life. Modern audiences tend to react negatively to its central plot: the “taming” of a strong-willed woman by a confident and determined husband. But for Catholic mothers—especially those pursuing Classical Catholic homeschooling in the spirit of the Church and the tradition of the Classical Liberal Arts—this play offers remarkable insights into both marriage and parenting. Understood rightly, it provides lessons that align with the natural law, the teaching of Scripture, and the order of domestic life as established by God.

Reading Shakespeare with Catholic Eyes

First, we must understand how to read Shakespeare. His plays are not sermons. They are dramatic reflections of human nature—its strengths, its follies, its triumphs, and its sins. Shakespeare was deeply influenced by Christian thought and by the ancient wisdom of Aristotle. Therefore, his plays often reveal moral truths through the outcomes of characters’ choices and the unfolding of providence.

The Taming of the Shrew is best read not as a comedy about male dominance or female submission, but as a parable about order, humility, virtue, and love in marriage and family life. It helps us ask: What happens when a household loses order? What kind of man brings peace to a woman’s soul? How can parents raise daughters and sons who embrace their roles with grace?

Let us walk through the lessons this play offers, especially for mothers striving to live out their vocations in faith.

What the Shrew Really Needed: The Healing Power of Order

Katherina, the “shrew” of the title, is not evil or mad. She is angry. Her sharp tongue, her refusal to submit, her loud rebellion against her father and suitors—all come from a soul out of harmony. From the first scenes, we see her bitterness and isolation. She is mocked and shunned. Her younger sister, Bianca, receives all the attention. Her father favors Bianca publicly. Katherina, full of wounded pride and ungoverned will, lashes out.

Now, St. Thomas Aquinas teaches in the Summa Theologica that the proper order of the soul—reason ruling the passions—is necessary for virtue. Katherina has lost that order. She does not know how to trust or yield because she does not believe she is safe or loved. Her father, Baptista, has failed to lead her well. He prefers peace over conflict and flatters Bianca’s sweetness rather than correcting her vanity. This mismanagement feeds Katherina’s resentment.

Enter Petruchio—not a perfect man, but a man of strength. Unlike the other suitors, he does not flatter or fear Katherina. He confronts her defiance with firm wit and cheerful resolve. He refuses to be bullied or discouraged. His goal is not merely to control her, but to win her.

His “taming” is not cruel. It is corrective. Through paradox, reversal, and playful authority, he teaches Katherina that peace comes through surrender—not to domination, but to right order.

This reflects a deeper truth taught in the Scriptures: “Wives should be subordinate to their husbands as to the Lord. For the husband is head of his wife just as Christ is head of the church…” (Ephesians 5:22–23). Katherina’s healing begins when she accepts Petruchio’s headship, which in turn requires Petruchio to act as a true head—not a tyrant, but a servant-leader, strong, wise, and loving.

What Catholic Mothers Can Learn for Their Marriages

Catholic mothers today often carry heavy burdens. They manage households, educate children, run businesses, cook meals, handle finances, and try to grow in faith. But in the stress of it all, they can forget—or resist—the proper order of marriage.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church reminds us that “the love of the spouses requires, of its very nature, the unity and indissolubility of the spouses’ community of persons, which embraces their entire life” (CCC 1644). Marriage is a partnership, but not a democracy. It is a covenant, modeled on the relationship between Christ and the Church. The husband is the head, the wife the heart. Each has dignity and authority, but not the same role.

Like Katherina, many modern wives suffer because they resist their husbands’ leadership. They feel alone and overburdened, yet they do not allow their husbands to lead. Often, this is because their husbands have not shown the strength and steadiness that deserves trust. But sometimes, even good men are blocked by wives who will not yield.

Petruchio’s model reminds us of the kind of husband a woman can safely follow. He is decisive. He is humorous. He is persistent. He does not give in to emotional games. Most importantly, he loves Katherina enough to lead her out of her misery and back into joyful womanhood.

Catholic mothers can reflect: Have I allowed my husband to lead our home? Do I support his decisions, or second-guess and resist? Do I complain about his weakness while refusing to create the space for him to grow strong?

The healing of marriage begins when a wife chooses to trust, and a husband chooses to lead with firmness and charity.

Raising Daughters: Teaching Humility and Trust

In raising daughters, mothers often focus on developing talents, confidence, and intelligence. These are good things. But if humility is not formed alongside them, the result is often a soul like Katherina’s—wounded, proud, and combative.

Bianca, Katherina’s sister, at first seems the better model. She is quiet, obedient, and gentle. But as the play progresses, we see she is not as virtuous as she appears. She is vain, flirtatious, and willful. Her sweetness masks a calculating heart. In the final scene, it is Katherina—not Bianca—who gives the speech about a wife’s duty, calling women to “place their hands below their husband’s foot” in a spirit of joyful submission.

This reversal is powerful. It shows that real transformation happens when a woman accepts her God-given role. Katherina, humbled and at peace, has found joy through obedience. Bianca, still flattered and indulged, has not matured.

Catholic mothers must teach their daughters that feminine virtue is not passivity, but receptivity. It is not weakness, but wisdom. As the Blessed Virgin Mary shows us, true greatness comes through saying, “Let it be done to me according to your word” (Luke 1:38). Daughters need to learn how to accept correction, wait patiently, and trust in the guidance of God and their fathers.

Aesop’s fable of “The Oak and the Reed” helps here. The proud oak falls in the storm, while the humble reed bends and survives. Our daughters will face many storms. We must teach them how to bend—not to compromise their faith, but to avoid destruction through pride.

Raising Sons: Forming Gentlemen Who Can Lead

Petruchio is a rare character. He is not crude, though he is bold. He is not harsh, though he is strong. He is not confused about his role. He is cheerful, daring, clever, and determined.

Many boys today lack models of masculine confidence and virtue. They are taught to be soft, confused, and apologetic. Or they swing to the other extreme, embracing crude, aggressive, unvirtuous masculinity.

Catholic mothers must raise sons who can become husbands like Petruchio—men who can tame shrews not by domination, but by presence, courage, and love.

St. Augustine teaches that “the good man, though a slave, is free; the wicked man, though a king, is a slave.” A true man is ruled by reason and virtue. He governs his passions, his words, and his household.

To form sons into such men, we must teach them discipline, self-sacrifice, and purpose. They must learn to work, to endure discomfort, to speak plainly and respectfully. They must be taught to read noble literature, love the truth, and cherish beauty. Most of all, they must learn to fear God and desire heaven.

Petruchio’s confidence came not from arrogance, but from a knowledge of his role. He understood what a husband was meant to be. Our sons must be given that vision—and trained to live it.

The Power of the Final Speech: True Feminine Strength

The most controversial part of The Taming of the Shrew is Katherina’s final speech. Yet when read with understanding, it is one of the most beautiful declarations of Christian womanhood in literature. She says:

“Thy husband is thy lord, thy life, thy keeper,
Thy head, thy sovereign; one that cares for thee…”

She goes on to describe the husband as one who toils and suffers for his wife’s ease, and the wife as one who owes him love, obedience, and peace.

This speech is not degrading—it is freeing. It describes a wife’s role not as a slave, but as a beloved helper. The Catechism explains, “The woman ‘submits’ to her husband in the sense that the Church submits to the headship of Christ… The love of husband and wife becomes an image of the absolute and unfailing love with which God loves” (CCC 1642).

In this light, Katherina’s words become a witness to truth. She has discovered that resisting her husband brought her misery, but obeying him has brought her peace. Her submission is not humiliation—it is harmony.

Final Encouragement for Catholic Mothers

If we read The Taming of the Shrew with modern feminist lenses, we will miss its wisdom. But if we read it as Catholics—believing in natural law, divine order, and the complementarity of man and woman—we will see it as a parable of restoration.

As Catholic mothers, we must:

  • Examine our own marriages and renew our commitment to the roles God has given us.
  • Teach our daughters to embrace femininity with humility and trust.
  • Form our sons into strong, virtuous men who can lead with confidence and gentleness.
  • Pray for grace to submit to one another out of reverence for Christ.

When we live this way, our homes become images of heaven. And like Petruchio and Katherina, we discover that true joy comes not from winning battles, but from loving rightly.

Mrs. Dania C. Michael, O.P.
Homeschool Support
Classical Liberal Arts Academy

Reflection Questions

  1. In what ways might I be resisting my husband’s leadership at home? Why?
  2. How can I better support my daughters in developing humility, patience, and trust?
  3. Am I helping my sons grow in strength, courage, and self-governance?
  4. What virtues do I need to ask God for in my own journey as a wife and mother?

Closing Prayer

Prayer for Order in the Home

Heavenly Father,
You are the source of all order and peace.
You created marriage to reflect the love between Christ and the Church.
Grant me grace to live out my vocation in joy and humility.
Help me to honor my husband, teach my children, and embrace my role.
Form in me a quiet and trusting heart, like Our Lady’s.
Bless our home with peace, laughter, and truth.
Through Christ our Lord. Amen.

Notes

Print Friendly, PDF & Email