How the Socratic Method Directs the Scientific Method

In this video, Mr. William C. Michael of the Classical Liberal Arts Academy puts ChatGPT to the test on the nature of light, which leads to a number of important conclusions. Mr. William C. MichaelClassical Liberal Arts Academy mail@classicalliberalarts.com For more resources from the Classical Liberal Arts Academy, visit: https://classicalliberalarts.com

Aristotle, Prior Analytics. Book I, Chapter 11

1. But in the last figure, when the terms are universally joined to the middle, and both the propositions are categoric, if either of them is necessary, the conclusion also will be necessary. If, however, one of the propositions is privative, but the other categoric; when the privative is necessary, … Read more

Aristotle, Prior Analytics. Book I, Chapter 10

1. In the second figure, however, if the privative proposition is necessary, the conclusion also will be necessary; but if the categoric proposition is necessary, the conclusion will not be necessary. 2. For, in the first place, let the primitive proposition be necessary, and let it not be possible for … Read more

Aristotle, Prior Analytics. Book I, Chapter 09

1. It also sometimes happens that one of the propositions being necessary, a necessary syllogism will be produced, yet not of either proposition casually, but of that which contains the greater extreme. 2. For instance, if A is assumed to be present or not present with B from necessity; but … Read more

Aristotle, Prior Analytics. Book I, Chapter 08

1. Since, however, to exist, to exist from necessity, and to exist contingently, are different; (for many things exist, indeed, yet not from necessity, but other things neither necessarily exist, nor, in short, exists, yet may happen to exist), it is evident, that there will be a different syllogism of … Read more

Aristotle, Prior Analytics. Book I, Chapter 07

1. It is likewise manifest, that in all the figures, when a syllogism is not produced, both the terms being categoric or privative, and particular, nothing necessary, in short, will be inferred. 2. But if the one is categoric, and the other privative, the privative being universally assumed, a syllogism … Read more

Aristotle, Topics. Book II, Chapter 05

Again, it is also a sophistical place, to bring the opponent to that against which we abound with arguments. But this will sometimes, indeed, be necessary, sometimes will appear to be necessary, and sometimes will neither appear to be, nor will be necessary. It is necessary, therefore, when he who … Read more

Aristotle, Topics. Book II, Chapter 04

The mutation also into a name more known is useful; as, for instance, the clear, instead of the accurate, in opinion; and the love of employment instead of being engaged in various occupations. For when that which is asserted becomes more known, the thesis may be more easily opposed. This … Read more

Aristotle, Topics. Book II, Chapter 03

Again, if anything should be multifariously predicated, but it is posited as inherent, or as not inherent, one of those things which are multifariously predicated must be proved, if both cannot be proved. But this place is to be used in things which are latent. For if it is not … Read more